WELL: I'm not exactly J.P.'s intended answerer, especially as libertarianism is the only major political orientation with which I have no sympathy.
It seems to me that the two have to be in tension with each other, because Christianity seems to imply a deontologist sense of ethics: certain things have to be morally unacceptable in all circumstances (e.g. murder is wrong). It seems to be a further consequence that these ethics are by their very nature at least partially coercive (so it does no good if you don't murder anyone if lots and lots of other people do). The essence of libertarianism (as it's always been presented to me) is to have the minimal possible level of governmental intrusion, so, for example, people should be free to drink, smoke, do drugs etc etc, so long as in doing so they hurt no one else. Now, especially if you subscribe to an evangelical form of Christianity, it seems like you can't be indifferent to the fate of other people to the level that libertarianism seems to require.
Do note the frequent use of 'seems.' I'm prepared on this one to be proven wrong, since there may be a way of closing that gap, though it doesn't occur to me right now.
"Thou shalt not extinguish thine anger, but shall master it,
that thy conscience may not be blunted by adjustment
to wrong causes."
-The Dutch Ten Commandments to Foil the Nazis
No comments:
Post a Comment